Stained Glass Cookies are a Christmas classic. Rolled sugar cookies are cut out and filled with crushed Jolly Rancher candies. As the cookies bake, the candies melt, creating a stained glass effect. Perfect for your holiday cookie tray!
These cookies look impressive and fancy and will have everyone “ooh-ing” and “ahh-ing.”
I absolutely love the way these cookies look and everyone always enjoys them whenever I make them, too.
These Stained Glass Cookies are Day 10 of our 12 Days of Cookies
Be sure to check out all of the other days for more goodies!
Day 1 – Fluffernutter Cookies
Day 2 – Toffee Coconut Oatmeal Bars
Day 3 – Double Chocolate M&M Christmas Cookies
Day 4 – Lace Cookies
Day 5 – Whipped Shortbread
Day 6 – Chocolate Spritz Cookies
Day 7 – 3 Ingredient Sugar Free PB Cookies
Day 8 – Wasabi Chocolate Crinkles
Day 9 – Christmas Sprinkle Cookies
Day 10 – You’re on it!
Day 11 – Cream Cheese Meltaways
Day 12 – Peppermint Sugar Cookie Cups
SAVE THIS EASY STAINED GLASS COOKIE RECIPE TO YOUR FAVORITE PINTEREST BOARD!
Sugar cookies with candy
Here’s the secret: they are super easy to make!
Stained Glass Window Cookies are just a simple sugar cookie using two cookie cutters, and crushed Jolly Rancher candies. The candies melt to fill the center of the cookie with a jewel toned layer that resembles stained glass.
You can make them into any shape you like and any colors you like. Unlike most holiday sugar cookie recipes, they require no frosting or sprinkles.
I love frosted sugar cookies too but sometimes it’s nice to have one less step (and less mess) on your baking day!
What do I need?
These cookies start with a homemade sugar cookie dough. For the dough, you’ll need these ingredients.
- butter
- sugar
- egg
- vanilla
- heavy cream
- flour
- salt
- baking powder
To make the stained glass center, you’ll need crushed jolly ranchers. Any color will do. I chose festive red and green for the holidays.
Put candies in plastic zipped bags. Use a mallet to crush them into fine pieces. They don’t need to be totally pulverized, just fine enough to melt quickly in the oven.
How to Make Stained Glass Christmas Cookies
First, you just mix together the sugar cookie dough and roll it out.
Then you’ll need two of the same shape cookie cutters, but different sizes.
Separate the Jolly Rancher candies by color and put them into sandwich bags.
Using a rolling pin or flat heavy mallet, crush the candy.
Use one cookie cutter to cut out the cookie shapes. Then use the smaller cookie cutter of the same shape to cut out the center.
Halfway through the baking time, you pull the sugar cookies out of the oven. Sprinkled crushed up candy into the center of each cookie. Put them back in the oven and let them finish baking as the candy melts.
PRO TIP: Be careful not to get any crushed candy on the actual cookie itself. Keep the cookie part clean and neat for best looking cookies!
Can I use life savers instead?
I’ve seen people online mention making Stained Glass Cookies with Life Savers instead of Jolly Ranchers. So I gave it a shot to find out if the results would be just as good.
My answer will always be a resounding no.
In the picture ABOVE, Lifesavers are on the left, Jolly Ranchers on the right. Even though it’s a blurry picture, you can still see the difference. Jolly Ranchers melt so much more smoothly than Life Savers. There’s no contest which candies work best in Stained Glass Cookies recipes. Jolly Ranchers will win every time.
These Stained Glass Sugar Cookies were a hit for Thanksgiving along with Caramel Apple Pie Crust Cookies. The kids LOVED them–and so did all the adults!
Sugar Cookies
Since we’re talking about sugar cookies today and especially Christmas cookies, I also don’t want to forget to talk about the other ones I love on this blog.
Classic Peppermint Frosted Sugar Cookies make your kitchen smell like candy cane heaven. These Peppermint Blossom Cookies bring tons of festivity to my Christmas cookie platters every year, too.
Have you made Viennese Crescents yet? Those are easy to make and fancy enough to serve at a more formal Christmas soiree or tea party.
Need a little more cookie inspiration? We’ve got you covered with these tasty sugar cookie recipes!
- Cranberry Ginger Sugar Cookies
- Jelly Roll Sugar Cookies
- Jam-Filled Sugar Cookies
- Cinnamon Sugar Cookies
- Coconut Macadamia Sugar Cookies
- Strawberry Buttercream Sugar Cookies
- Cream Cheese Cookies
- Jackie’s Vanilla Cut-Out Sugar Cookies
~ FOLLOW ME ~
~ FACEBOOK ~ PINTEREST ~
~ INSTAGRAM ~ TWITTER ~
SIGN UP FOR THE WEEKLY
365 DAYS OF BAKING & MORE
NEWSLETTER!
Turn simple sugar cookies into an eye-catching treat with this Stained Glass Cookies Recipe!
Stained Glass Cookies
Equipment
- Mixer
- mixing bowl
- Baking Sheet
Ingredients
- 8 tablespoons unsalted butter room temperature
- ¾ cup granulated sugar
- 1 egg
- ½ teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 1 tablespoon heavy cream
- 1 ½ cups all-purpose flour
- ⅛ teaspoon salt
- ¼ teaspoon baking powder
- Assorted Jolly Rancher Hard Candies 10-15 of each, crushed – I put them in two plastic bags and crushed them with a mallet and you can use any color you prefer.
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees, F.
- Prepare two baking sheet by lining them with parchment paper.
- Cream the butter, then gradually add the sugar, beating until light.
- Add the egg, vanilla and cream. Beat throughly.
- In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together the flour, salt and baking powder.
- Add to the butter/sugar mixture and blend well.
- Prepare a clean flat surface by covering it with flour, enough so that the dough will not stick to the surface.
- Using a floured rolling pin, roll dough to 1/4 -inch thick.
- Using the larger cookie cutter, cut shapes into the dough.
- Transfer the cut-outs to prepared cookie sheets.
- Center the smaller cookie cutter in to the larger cut-out and gently remove.
- Bake cookies for 5 minutes, until slightly set.
- Remove tray from oven and with a small spoon or small utensil sprinkle crushed Jolly Rancher candy into the center of each cookie.
- Return tray to oven and bake for 5-7 minutes more, until candy has melted and cookies are golden.
- Allow to cool on baking sheet for about 5 minutes before setting on wire rack to cool completely.
Notes
Nutrition
This post was originally published 12/8/2013. It has been updated in format and with new pictures on 12/6/2021.
I took the sugar cookie recipe from my Fannie Farmer Cookbook Thirteenth Edition, p. 617; author, Marion Cunningham; publisher, Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Random House, Inc.; ISBN 0-394-56788-9.
Christmas Cookies
Check out more recipes from the 12 Days of Cookies past!
- Chocolate Chip Caramel Peanut Butter Pretzel Cookies
- Pumpkin Spice White Chocolate Cookies
- Cranberry Ginger Sugar Cookies
- Salted Caramel Thumbprints
- Greek Honey-Walnut Cookies
- Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies
- Mexican Wedding Cookies
Comments & Reviews
Dough was too soft couldn’t roll or cut
I haven’t made these yet, but is it possible to place the small cutter back into the middle and then pour the candy into that, then remove the cutter? Would that possibly work to avoid splatter on the cookies??
Elaine,
I think that’s a great idea and worth a shot. Please let me know how it goes!
Hi,
I just did this technique with sunglasses-shaped cookies for school-year-end. They turned out great with the Jolly Rancher candies. I found that one Lifesavers candy wasn’t enough to fill as the lens and they did bubble up like you’ve shown. I also didn’t crunch up the candy first. I just put the candy in the hole as is. They filled the lens quite nicely. You’ll find that they melt quite quickly and then they start to bubble. However, when you take the cookies out, you can dissipate the bubbles by stirring the liquid candy to get rid of them. Then let the candy settle and the candy will cool smooth like the end result you’ll be expecting.
Arjay, that’s so wonderful to hear. Thanks so much for the tip – I never would have thought of that! And what a great treat to end the school year. Love it!
Hi I just made these and they look very pretty. Heres the problem, I find it difficult to get it off they trays. They stuck to paper. Any ideas to get them off smoothly? Thanks.
.
Tricia, I apologize for my late response. I would use parchment and spray that with some cooking spray to help as well.
“Lifesavers are on the right, Jolly Ranchers on the left. Even though it’s a blurry picture, you can still see the difference.”
You have the left and right mixed up. Fix the text to match the picture.
When you say cream , what kind of cream are you talking about ?
Jolene,
I used heavy cream in this recipe and have made note of that in the ingredients.
Thank you!
Where does one find these double cookie cutters, Would be nice if you had them for sale on this site
Verona, I believe I found them years ago through Amazon. Unfortunately, I can’t remember exactly.
I have read every stained glass cookie recipe there is and it is obvious to me that you are the only one that knows what they are doing..if you put the candy in the cookies before you bake them it bubbles up and they do not go away like all these other writers say..you have to only let the candy just come to a melting stage and then take them out..so thank you..
Debby, that makes me so happy to hear. Thank you so much. I can’t stand when the bubbles appear in the candy. I found that the cookies bake better and the candy tends to stay more centered than melting all over the place if putting the crushed candy in at the beginning, too.
Now I want a stained glass cookie!! 😉
❤️
Lynne,
I need the help of a real pro.. I am making these cookies to put in gift baskets but I am afraid that someone is not going to realize what it is and break a front tooth..kinda ruins the happy gift basket experience..haha..anyway can you think of anything else I could put in the center that would not dry as hard..? I realize that they won’t be as pretty or give the stained glass look. I just want the concept.. I have put different colored dough in the center but I want something really cool looking for my baskets..thanks for any help you might have..
also if you have a business email could you email it to me..?. I am kinda new at this and I have questions sometimes if you wouldn’t mind.. I don’t trust some of these others as much..who knows..you might just get a gift basket in return..!
Debby, you’re so sweet!
While the stained glass cookies would be beautiful in a gift basket, I can understand your concern.
My suggestion would be to make either some thumbprint cookies or Linzer cookies with jam in the center.
I do have a Peanut Butter and Jelly Thumbprint cookie here on the blog, but have not make any Linzer cookies as of yet. Thought I do have those cookie cutters sitting in my cupboard whenever I finally get around to making them. 😂
And my business email is 365daysofbakingandmore@gmail.com.
Good luck with your new venture! How exciting!
For the jolly rancher recipe to work try melting the jolly rancher first then poor it in the hole and let it cool the cookie as to be cooked already of course